Nation ePublications   

EDITORIAL – Cellphone ban a good call

Sat, August 21, 2010 - 12:00 AM

A decade after cellphones became the rage in Barbados their widespread use and abuse are threatening public safety. That’s particularly true of motorists who engage in endless chatter at the wheel.

Minister of Transport and Works John Boyce’s warning rang loudly last week when he said: “Regrettably, our records show that inappropriate use of this instrument while driving has contributed to our traffic accidents.”

 And in an attempt to curb the use of phones while driving, he announced: “To correct the situation we are proposing to ban the use of hand-held mobile phones on the highway unless a hands-free device is in use.”

Although it’s a sensible move, the Government shouldn’t be under any illusion that it is foolproof. If the administration goes ahead with its plan, it would put Barbados on a list of at least 50 nations worldwide that have instituted such a ban. Penalties range from US$22 in Austria for the first offence to 2 000 euros and a jail sentence of two weeks behind bars in The Netherlands.

There is little doubt, as borne out by scientific studies, that cellphone use, except in cases of hands-free while driving, causes accidents, and is a danger not simply to the offender but to other motorists and to pedestrians. A key factor is the distraction it causes, reducing the driver’s awareness of what’s happening on the road.

The proliferation of cellphone use in Barbados is a fact of life, a reflection of the modernity that has gripped the world. According to World Bank statistics, the number of mobile telephone subscribers in Barbados went from 107 for every 1 000 Bajans in 2000 to 765 for every 1 000 by 2005. In the four to five years since then, it would not be unreasonable to estimate that there’s a cellphone for every person in the island, just as in Britain.

Some scientists who studied the problem have gone so far as to equate the dangers of cellphone abuse behind the wheel with driving while intoxicated. And they advise that in much the same way we encourage people to have designated drivers, persons who don’t drink, then we should take away the mobile phone from those who engage in “long-talk 24/7”.

After all, vehicles in motion can be dangerous weapons and are treated as such in several jurisdictions.

It’s almost routine these days to be cut off on our streets by drivers so intent on talking on their cellphones that they don’t signal their intentions. And there are times when we have looked in the rear-view mirror and watched with horror as the driver behind didn’t notice we had stopped, all because he or she is on the cellphone.

But there is another side to this story. Other studies have failed to show any substantial benefits from the imposition of legal bans in the United States.

Still, we believe that the risks are great enough to merit action. If changing the law can save a life, or prevent serious injury then it is worth it.

The challenge for the police will be enforcement. Cops will have to be constantly on the lookout for those who flout the law and they can only take action if they are mobile. Giving drivers a citation and hauling them into court isn’t an easy task. Other countries have found that to be true.

Clearly, for any ban to be effective there must be enforcement and that would necessitate a stiff penalty that would deter would-be abusers.

Just as important is an information and education campaign that underscores the need for common sense behind the wheel.

After all, the next life you save may be your own.

  • Editor's Choice

Share your thoughts

Please sign in or register to post your comments.

Page 1 of 1 pages

Posted by Cannon Rowe 1 year, 5 months ago

Some organisations , like the Police,BDF and Ambulance Service will be exempt the Cell Phone Ban. What mechanism will be put in place to ensure that calls made by these entities are work-related and not personal?

  • 0
  • 0
Posted by Jormac 1 year, 5 months ago

The Banning of cell phones while driving may be a good thing, the problem will be if people will stop using these devices while driving which is very unlikely. Once people can do things and get away with them they will continue doing them, and the LAW can’t be all over the place to see the wrongs people are doing. As a people we need to have constance monitoring in order to get results as long as one can get away with doing wrong they will continue doing it.

  • 0
  • 0
Posted by Jennifer West 1 year, 5 months ago

Emergency vehicles have two way radios installed, no need for them to use a mobile phone! On the spot fines should be considered.Most vehicles can be fitted with a voice activated device for mobiles, if not, drivers should pull over and take the call or ignore it and return the car when stationary.They should think-Is that call really worth a life?

  • 0
  • 0
Posted by Steven Mitchell 1 year, 4 months ago

In the United States, the reason why the laws prohibiting cellphone use have failed is because the penalties are so minimal that people ignore the ban. The laws in the US are not considered traffic offenses in most states, so it is rarely enforced. For example, in New York State it is a $60 fine with no points on your driving record, no required court appearance and no consequences for higher insurance. The newer problem that has emerged is with people texting on their cellphone while driving which mechanically and mentally requires a significantly greater diversion of concentration from driving. It has caused a number of well-publicized deaths, especially by engineers of commuter trains, subways and the like. If you are going to pass laws in Barbados that you expect to be effective, they need to have accompanying consequences for a violation of the law that will deter behavior.

  • 0
  • 0

Page 1 of 1 pages

Recent Comments

Latest Videos

Quick Poll

Do you agree with Andrew Bynoe's suggestion that there be a 10 per cent pay cut across the board in Barbados?

View Past Polls

Stay Connected to Your World

Join Your Friends & Our Community

Your Friends' Activity

Daily Cartoons

  • Monday, February 13, 2012 - 2012 02 12
  • February 12, 2012 - 2012 02 12
  • Saturday February 11, 2012 cover - 2012 02 11

Photo Gallery