Last Updated: Saturday, November 21, 2009 : 12:14 AM
Member Name:
Password:



Home / Commentary _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

Commentary
Tools: Print  |  E-mail  |   Bookmark and Share
Marriage of convenience a human right

 

Published on: 11/4/2009.


IT WOULD BE iniquitous if a law restricting marriages of convenience ostensibly to control immigration into Barbados were to be passed before integrity legislation intended to keep politicians and public officials honest.

The caution is that special cases make bad law.

Marriages of convenience are historical (if not traditional) and have different motives, the least of which is to assume a foreign nationality. They occur for larger economic, social, and religious reasons as well as enhancement of ethnic status.

Adherence to a particular political party without full conviction of its dogma (if any) is as much a marriage of convenience as marrying the boss' daughter for more obvious reasons than passion.

Immigration should be regulated in the same manner as tourism in a continuum of fundamental human rights with tourists at one end and citizens at the other. Between the extremes of visitor or stranger and domicile there would be visas of varying duration and privilege.

The essential control is a matter of accommodation. There must be some regulation of population size in proportion to space and availability of resources to ensure progressive development and maintenance of the amenity of the place.

In the exercise of such control, discrimination on grounds of race, place of origin, political opinions, colour, creed or sex in any form of legislation would be a violation of the Fundamental Rights and Freedoms of the Individual guaranteed by the Barbados Independence Order 1966 qua, "Constitution of Barbados".

Marriage involves an expression of the freedom of conscience and association which cannot morally or "constitutionally" be prohibited.

- LEONARD ST HILL

Subject:
Body:
Poster:
captcha 48c86e728bfb4546a5e392d01195188c
Enter text seen above:
4 comment found!

marriage : 11/7/2009
Not only non-nationals married for convenience, some of our own get married for what they can get out of a marriage, when they can't get they will move on or find someone else that will give them. Nothing real about living up to the VOWS anymore those are just words.

mcndurh

: 11/6/2009
Government has a right and obligation to police visa fraud. A fraudulent marriage is morally wrong and government would be seriously negligent in failing to prohibit such marriages which potentially have such serious implications for the sociological and economical well being of this society.


hi : 11/5/2009
What about after marriage?How is life then?

hi

: 11/4/2009
Basically you are saying that it is okay for some to make a profit from others who are desperate to get citizenship because these marriages of conveniences are not done out of the goodness of someone's heart it is done for a price the world over there is big money being made out of marriages of convenience. Also in some places people are forced into marriage so as a person can gain citizenship so before you disagree with the change in law about marriage of convenience please research the negative aspects of this practice it is not as clear cut as you may believe.



More Commentary News


TODAY'S CARTOONS
11/18/2009



Most Emailed Stories









© 1997-2007. Nation Publishing Company Limited. | Privacy Statement | Terms of Use
News | Comments | Lifestyle | Media | E-Paper& Archives | Subscriptions | Advertising | Classifieds | Blogs